Essay about Personal Identity: Philosophical Views | …
At this point, the discussion turns to questions about self governance and autonomy. The ethical landscape of questions related to the personal identity and wishes of people who have undergone grave psychological changes because of disease proves to be challenging terrain. Ken and John, in addition to our guest Raymond, attempt to sort out and make sense of the implications of personal identity for rationality and morality.
Personal identity essays - Selfguidedlife
384): Continuityof memory is not strictly required for personal identity through time. I might be stricken with total amnesia, yet I am still , WGL. (I would then have to relearn that I am in fact WGL.) Objection 2 (Penelhum, pp.
Ken and John begin this week’s episode by discussing what philosophers mean by personal identity, and why they think such a thing exists. Ken proposes a simple definition: personal identity is simply the same thing we mean when we talk about the identity of two objects, where the objects just happen to be people. But John disagrees. He argues that people mean something very different when they refer to the identity of persons. He thinks there’s a psychological sense of identity that is most important to people when they are referring to who they are. Even still, Ken counters, there is always just one person who is undergoing changes over the course of his/her life. So what does this psychological sense matter? Thus begins the debate about personal identity.
Philosophy Paper #1: Personal Identity -- Philosophy
Others take a more idealist approach with the belief that mental continuity is the sole factor in establishing personal identity holding that physical things are just reflections of the mind.
02/02/2018 · Philosophy Paper #1: Personal Identity ..
The problem of personal identity is determining what conditions and qualities are necessary and sufficient for a person to exist as the same being at one time as another.
Philosophy Paper #1: Personal Identity - 1056 Words | …
One more perspective on personal identity and the one I will attempt to explain and defend in this paper is that personal identity requires both physical and psychological continuity; my argument is as follows:
1) Bodily continuity is required for the function of mental continuity.
Personal Identity in Philosophy Essay Sample
The Cartesian theory If Descartes mind-body Dualism is correct, the answerto the question of personal identity is simple: A is the same asB if As body is animated by the same Cartesian mind/soul/ego as was Bsbody.
Personal Identity: Locke and Hume - University …
What is necessary for a person to survive over time? Is it the continued existence of the living body? Or is it just the living brain? Or is it one's psychology, which might persist even without one's original brain in a computer or in an entirely new brain? How important are questions of personal identity for ethics and rationality? John and Ken are joined by Raymond Martin, Professor of Philosophy at Union College and co-author of .
Personal Identity: Locke and Hume ..
At this point, Raymond Martin enters into the discussion to try and help clear up the confusion between Ken and John. Ken queries Raymond as to why he should plan for the future, why he should care about the old guy he is going to grow into. Caring about ones future self can become a very confusing concern when you consider different thought experiments regarding personal identity. By looking at the intuitive judgments people have in response to these experiments, it is possible to understand what matters most to individuals when they are acting out of concern for their future self. Ken, John, and Raymond enter into a trying debate about psychological and bodily criterions of personal identity, and attempt to discern whether there is a correct answer about which captures the essence of personal identity best. What happens when your body undergoes drastic changes, do you remain the same person? What if those changes effect your mind, like in the case of Alzeimer’s disease?